Randy Orton is undoubtedly one of the most decorated and respected Superstars in WWE history. A 14-time World Champion and a future Hall of Famer, Orton has done it all. However, his recent victory in the semi-finals of the 2025 King of the Ring tournament has sparked debate among fans and critics alike. While his legacy is unquestioned, Orton’s win may have done more harm than good for WWE’s long-term storytelling and roster development. Here are three reasons why Randy Orton winning the King of the Ring 2025 semi-finals was a mistake.
—
1. Missed Opportunity to Elevate a Rising Star
The King of the Ring tournament has historically served as a launching pad for up-and-coming talent. Superstars like Bret Hart, Stone Cold Steve Austin, and Booker T all used the crown as a stepping stone to superstardom. In 2025, WWE had a golden opportunity to give the spotlight to a younger or underutilized performer—someone who could benefit from a major push. Instead, they opted for a well-established name in Orton, who doesn’t need the rub.
Talents like Carmelo Hayes, Bron Breakker, or even Ilja Dragunov were prime candidates to step into the spotlight. A semi-final win—and potentially a tournament victory—could have elevated one of them to main-event status. Orton’s win, while nostalgic, feels like a step backward in an era where WWE desperately needs to build its next generation of stars.
—
2. It Stalls Fresh Storytelling Opportunities
Orton’s win in the semi-finals continues a trend of relying on legacy stars rather than embracing bold new directions. While he remains incredibly popular, most of Orton’s storylines have been thoroughly explored. A newer talent advancing could have opened the door to fresh rivalries, new character arcs, and exciting matchups on weekly television.
Instead, Orton’s involvement in the finals feels like WWE playing it safe. Fans already know what to expect from “The Viper”—slow, methodical promos and familiar in-ring tactics. A newer face in the finals could have introduced unpredictability and shaken up WWE’s creative flow. Orton’s win keeps the spotlight on the past rather than building toward the future.
—
3. Risk of Overshadowing the Tournament’s Purpose
The King of the Ring is meant to crown a wrestler ready to ascend to greatness. When someone like Orton—already a living legend—advances deep into the tournament, it dilutes the prestige of the event. Rather than becoming a star-making vehicle, the tournament becomes another accolade for someone who already has plenty.
If Orton wins the whole thing, it could be seen as WWE using nostalgia to mask creative stagnation. Even his presence in the finals risks overshadowing whoever he faces, turning the focus to Orton’s legacy rather than the future of the company. The King of the Ring should be about defining what’s next, not reliving what’s already been.
—
Conclusion
Randy Orton is a legend, but his win in the 2025 King of the Ring semi-finals feels like a misstep. WWE had a real chance to create a breakout moment for a rising star, inject new energy into its storytelling, and preserve the tournament’s legacy as a launchpad for the future. Instead, the company leaned on the past—and that decision may co
st them momentum in the long run.
